Subs and Celebs At The New Jersey Mike's

"I'm so glad you're here!" a fiftysomething woman gleefully clutching a sandwich tray says to me. I'm puzzled for a moment, and then I realize that she's mistaken me for an employee of the sub shop, because I'm standing there holding a folder.

"You mean Jersey Mike's?" I ask.

"Yes!" she exclaims. "I'm from Jersey, and I haven't been able to find sandwiches like the ones back home until I found this place. I'm so glad you're here," she repeats.

"So they're as good as you remember?"

"Just like I grew up with," she smiles, and then the woman floats back over to her table on a cloud of cold cut joy. From the looks of her, I can tell this lady's eaten a sandwich or two in her day, and this place has made her so very, very happy that she's anxious to tell that to anybody who'll listen.

Smilin' Steve Yeager
It's not just former residents of the Garden State who are excited about the arrival of a Jersey Mike's in Granada Hills; Dodger fans are just as excited to stream into the sub shop's doors. That's because on most days, you can find tri-World Series MVP Steve Yeager in the shop, lending a hand and chatting up customers.

"But don't make the article about me," Yeager says. "It's all Charlene and Jillian's baby." The amiable and garrulous former Dodger, once called "the best-throwing catcher in the game," is here in a supporting role; the shop is primarily run by his wife Charlene Yeager and her partner Jillian Armenta, with help from Steve and from Jillian's husband James.

"I was taken out of retirement to be the Wal-Mart style Jersey Mike's meeter-greeter, slash busboy, errand boy, delivery boy," Steve says. And I'm having a great time. I get to talk to people about sports, politics, they come by to say hi. I'm here at lunch and dinner, then I help clean up at night. James and I do what we can do to support them and to help them out." Each couple has a son who works at the store as well, so the venture isn't just a double date, but a family affair.

Jillian Armenta and Charlene Yeager
I ask for Jersey Mike's signature sub, and I'm given the No. 13, the Original Italian. No. 13's point of pride is its three types of ham — traditional, cappacuolo (which everyone else in the world spells "cappocollo"), a spiced ham, and prosciuttini, a peppered prosciutto — and what they call "the juice," a blend of herbs, vinegar, and olive oil.

The olive oil, fragrant and fruity, is assertive in the finished product, and a pleasant surprise; the spices in the ham trio and in the salami and pepperoni are piquant. In short, it's a damn solid sub. I ate half and wrapped up the second half for later; by the time I got to it, the vinaigrette had saturated the bread and the flavors had wedded; it had actually improved with age. "A lot of people are afraid we're putting too much oil and vinegar, but really, that's the key to it," Jillian says. "It rolls off the tomatoes and soaks into the lettuce. That's what makes it blend together."

Charlene and Jillian have been partners for more than ten years, but not in a sandwich shop; formerly, the duo ran a mortgage business. "But we knew the mortgage business was coming to an end, and Charlene used to own a deli before, so we went back to our roots," Jillian explains. "We still have our mortgage business, but it's just obviously not as busy as this is now."

In this very different business setting, there is one key similarity — namely, that Charlene and Jillian are still the ones in charge ("We're both very bossy," Charlene laughs) — and one key difference: "The work is a lot more physical!" says Jillian. "Baking the bread, being on the slicer, you get sore arms."

"Plus the 17-18 hour days during our first month," Charlene adds. "The first month was tough. We were here 110 hours a week. We put a trailer in the back so we could take little naps." As if to illustrate her point, a delivery man stops by and, seeing Charlene and I in a booth together, says with a look of surprise, "Hey — you're sitting down!"

Charlene shoots back, "It won't last!" And it doesn't; moments later, she and Jillian are back in the kitchen, preparing to face the already accumulating lunch crowd. It's a far cry from the mortgage business, but it seems to make people a lot happier — even the ones who aren't from Jersey.


  1. YAY there's finally a Jersey Mike's in Granada Hills! :D

  2. Yay, and there's a printable coupon you can use on this page!

  3. Charlene, you haven't changed a bit. Congrats on your hard work & success with Jersey Mike's.

  4. I look forward to trying a Jersey Mikes sub
    and meeting Dodger great, Steve Yeager.

    Go Dodgers!

  5. Hi Steve, just wanted to say hi, and congrads on the wifes shop, Im still painting, regards gary drexler

  6. I enjoy the #7 (Steve Yeager) turkey sandwich on wheat, Mikes Way, with mustard and a side of jalapeno chips. This is my favorite. #7 was Steve Yeager's team number when he played for the Dodgers. Wednesday night I had the BBQ beef regular sized sandwich with the jalapeno chps. The sweet bbq sauce with the spicy chips was an excellent compliment.

  7. Love the #7 turkey. Steve was an old friend from the past. My significant other, friends and I are planning a trip to Granada Hills and will definitely check you guys out and would love to connect with Steve. Please ask him to reach out to us at or
    text at 914 403 5333.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Archive: Master of Pirates

Thoughts on Joe's Cafe and cancel culture

Another Skirmish In The Food Truck War