Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Why Nothing Will Change On May 21

The March 12 issue of New Scientist offers an explanation of doomsday cult thinking in an article by psychologist Richard Wiseman:

"In 1954, psychologist Leon Festinger of the University of Minnesota investigated a cult in Chicago that was convinced that the end of the world was nigh. The leader, Dorothy Martin, prophesied that there would be a great flood on 21 December and that a flying saucer would rescue her and her follower just before disaster occurred.

Festinger had several observers infiltrate the group and record what happened. As the appointed time approached, the members were buoyant and worked hard to spread word of the impending catastrophe. However, when 21 December came and went without any flooding or extraterrestrial visitation the mood changed.

Did the group suddenly change its beliefs in the face of overwhelming evidence? No. Instead, members concluded that they must have averted the cataclysm by spreading the word.

Festinger's investigation led him to develop the theory of cognitive dissonance. According to this idea, people find it uncomfortable to hold two conflicting beliefs in their head at the same time, and will perform all sorts of mental gymnastics to reconcile the two.

When evidence conflicts with cherished beliefs, most people are happier to explain away even the most compelling data rather than abandon their beliefs. So smokers will question research showing links between their habit and ill health rather tan give up, drivers convicted of speeding will convince themselves that the speed limits are too low rather than conclude that they put lives at risk, and politicians will argue for the effectiveness of their policies even when their ideas have obviously failed.

This approach pervades our everyday lives and helps our beliefs emerge unscathed through even the most devastating of evidential attacks."

6 comments:

  1. The thing I love most about these billboards is the hand about to write in the datebook. Is the end of the world something one needs to schedule like a dentist appointment? "Whoops! I almost forgot Judgment Day was next week! Note to self: buy new underwear."

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'll probably be stuck in traffic when Jesus starts picking the lucky numbers and makes the big ubertsunami, and I'll miss it all, and, as we now know from this whole terranucleotsunami mess, I won't be able to access the internet to find out what's going on. Darn the luck.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jesus is already here and in the body of Bill Maher.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Swim out past the breakers...

    ReplyDelete

There was an error in this gadget